PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack vs Pooch & Mutt - Puppy Superfood Complete Dry Dog Food Grain Free (Regular Sized Kibble), Chicken, 1.5kg
Side-by-side comparison of scores, ingredients, prices and real customer feedback for PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack and Pooch & Mutt - Puppy Superfood Complete Dry Dog Food Grain Free (Regular Sized Kibble), Chicken, 1.5kg.
Last verified: 07 Apr 2026 · Based on 27 reviews
PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack scores 79.0/100 vs Pooch & Mutt - Puppy Superfood Complete Dry Dog Food Grain Free (Regular Sized Kibble), Chicken, 1.5kg at 78.0/100. PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack wins on nutritional value, palatability. Pooch & Mutt - Puppy Superfood Complete Dry Dog Food Grain Free (Regular Sized Kibble), Chicken, 1.5kg is stronger on ingredient quality and value for money.
How Do the Scores Compare?
PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healt...
Pro Plan
|
Pooch & Mutt - Puppy Superf...
Pooch & Mu
|
|
|---|---|---|
| Overall Score | 79.0 | 78.0 |
| Ingredient Quality | 78.0/100 |
80.0/100
Best
|
| Nutritional Value |
84.0/100
Best
|
75.0/100 |
| Value for Money | 65.0/100 |
72.0/100
Best
|
| Transparency | 72.0/100 |
76.0/100
Best
|
| Palatability |
91.0/100
Best
|
87.0/100 |
| Best Price | £15.00 Amazon UK → |
£6.00
Amazon UK →
Cheapest
|
| Form | ||
| Dose | ||
| Third-Party Tested | ✗ No | ✗ No |
| Reviews Analysed | 12 | 15 |
PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy St...
Pros
- ✓Named chicken as #1 ingredient — no by-products, no meat meal
- ✓Colostrum inclusion supports immune defences and gut microbiome in young puppies
- ✓Excellent palatability across multiple breeds, including reported fussy eaters
- ✓Complete and balanced for puppy growth — DHA, Vitamin D, calcium/phosphorus ratios for bone and joint development
Cons
- ✗Premium pricing with a small 3kg pack — cost per kg is high compared to mid-market alternatives
- ✗Full ingredient list not disclosed in listing — likely contains grain-based carbohydrate fillers (corn, wheat, rice) typical of Pro Plan formulas
- ✗Sized and formulated for medium breeds (10–25kg); several reviewers using it for toy/small breeds, which is an off-label use
- ✗Oversized cardboard packaging noted as wasteful by buyers
Best For
Pooch & Mutt - Puppy Superfood C...
Pros
- ✓Named chicken as primary protein — no vague 'meat derivatives' or anonymous by-products
- ✓Microalgae oil provides DHA directly, supporting puppy brain and retinal development (FEDIAF-recommended source)
- ✓Very high palatability: multiple fussy eaters converted, empty-bowl reports across reviews
- ✓Functional ingredients (pumpkin, prebiotics, salmon oil) support gut health and coat quality
Cons
- ✗Multiple reports of loose stools and diarrhea, particularly in very young puppies (under 10 weeks) or during abrupt transition
- ✗Grain-free formulas are under ongoing FDA scrutiny for potential links to DCM (dilated cardiomyopathy) in some breeds — not confirmed causal, but worth monitoring especially for predisposed breeds (Golden Retrievers, Dobermans)
- ✗Full guaranteed analysis (precise protein %, calcium:phosphorus ratio) not provided in listing — harder to verify FEDIAF puppy growth minimums independently
- ✗1.5 kg pack size is small and may be costly per kg for medium-to-large breed puppies with higher intake needs
Best For
What does the data say about PRO PLAN Medium Puppy ... vs Pooch & Mutt - Puppy S...?
Pro Plan Medium Puppy Healthy Start uses named chicken as its primary ingredient with no listed by-products or meat meal, placing it among the more transparent mainstream puppy kibbles on the market.
What are the key differences?
Frequently Asked Questions
Which is better, PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack or Pooch & Mutt - Puppy Superfood Complete Dry Dog Food Grain Free (Regular Sized Kibble), Chicken, 1.5kg? ▼
Is PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack worth the price compared to Pooch & Mutt - Puppy Superfood Complete Dry Dog Food Grain Free (Regular Sized Kibble), Chicken, 1.5kg? ▼
Which has fewer side effects? ▼
Related Product Comparisons
Alpha Sporting Puppy Dry Dog Food
vs PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack
Alpha Sporting Puppy Dry Dog Food
vs Pooch & Mutt - Puppy Superfood Complete Dry Dog Food Grain Free (Regular Sized Kibble), Chicken, 1.5kg
Kibble + Raw Puppy Food - Free Run Turkey (5 x 1.5kg) ❘ Nutritious High Protein Kibble Combined with Freeze-Dried Raw Meat Nuggets, Contains Essential Oils & Minerals, Grain & Gluten Free
vs PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack
Kibble + Raw Puppy Food - Free Run Turkey (5 x 1.5kg) ❘ Nutritious High Protein Kibble Combined with Freeze-Dried Raw Meat Nuggets, Contains Essential Oils & Minerals, Grain & Gluten Free
vs Pooch & Mutt - Puppy Superfood Complete Dry Dog Food Grain Free (Regular Sized Kibble), Chicken, 1.5kg
PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack
vs James Wellbeloved Dog Puppy Hypoallergenic Dry Food Turkey and Rice 2 kg
PRO PLAN Medium Puppy Healthy Start up to 12-15 Months Dry Dog Food Chicken 3kg Pack
vs Lily’s Kitchen Made with Natural Ingredients Puppy Recipe With Chicken Wet Dog Food Tray (10 x 150g)
Disclaimer: AIScored provides data-driven comparisons based on publicly available reviews. This is not medical advice. Affiliate links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you.
Feedback & Suggestions
Spotted an issue? Wrong price, incorrect data, or something else off? Let us know and we'll fix it.
Missing a product you'd like us to review? Tell us the product name and we'll consider adding it.